7 Tips for How to Buy Beanie Babies

Beanie Babies, those adorable little pellet-filled toys that created a frenzy in the ’90s. Many thought of Beanie Babies as an investment that would go up in value. This was thanks to creator Ty Warner’s limited production runs and forced scarcity that caused people to buy Beanie Babies by the truckload.

Nostalgia and cuteness factors still make these toys desirable today. While you may not stumble across an overlooked Princess the Bear for $500,000, you can still find these cuddly little bean bag toys online in some places. 

If you’re looking for tips for where to buy Beanie Babies, you’ve come to the right place. We’ve compiled a list of places where you can buy Beanie Babies online. Keep reading to discover more about buying Beanie Babies.

1. Etsy

Etsy was once exclusively an online marketplace site for independent artists who sold their handmade goods and custom crafts through a digital storefront.

But now they have expanded to also selling vintage items. In case you don’t feel old enough already, to qualify as “vintage” on Etsy, items must be at least 20 years old.  

A simple search for Beanie Babies on Etsy turns up some interesting results about handmade beanies for babies but sprinkled in between are listings for many Beanie Babies in lots and singular form.

Many are categorized by their types, such as rodents, insects, birds, or sea life. Some are as cheap as $2.95, while there are still the high-priced collector Beanie Babies for $4,500 to $15,000.

2. Amazon.com

Amazon.com enlists third-party sellers on its site. These items are either sold by a merchant and shipped by the same merchant, or they are sold by a merchant and shipped through Amazon.

On a Beanie Baby listing’s page, when you scroll down, you’ll see that an item is sold by a particular seller name, but it is shipped by Amazon. This means you can buy third-party merchandise that is backed by Amazon’s guarantee. Amazon has this stock in its own warehouses to ship out.

If an item is shipped and sold by the same seller, that means they are responsible for processing and shipping it to you. They are only using Amazon as a platform to advertise and take payment. You’ll also see Amazon-sponsored ad listings in the results.

You may again have to filter out what Amazon thinks is searching for ‘beanies for babies’ and select Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys in the filter section to get over 3,000 results. Once you find the special Beanie companion that speaks to you, just Add to Cart.

3. eBay

eBay helped fuel the Beanie Baby craze in the late 90s with their bidding platform. Here, users from all across the nation could search for and bid on these supposed rare Beanie Babies and drive up their prices. 

Today, however, many of eBay’s Beanie Baby listings come with a fixed price where a user can ‘Buy It Now’ for the amount the seller has listed. This takes some of the fun out of the once-frantic bidding wars, but if you’re someone who buys Beanie Babies more leisurely, it is still a great platform for buying Beanie Babies online.

There are over 380,000 listings for buying Beanie Babies but you can always narrow it down with more specific search terms and filter settings.

4. Mercari

Mercari is a buying and selling website and app where users can sell their unwanted items to other users. It’s like an online yard sale. You can flip items for a profit and see what others have to sell that may interest you. 

Over 100,000 items get added each day, so there’s always something new to see. You can find and buy Beanie Babies that are vintage, licensed, sold in lots, or separately. You can also search by highest and lowest price parameters, by best match, the newest listings, and the number of likes an item may have.

5. Poshmark

Poshmark is another online marketplace app that specializes in reselling high-end goods such as clothing, shoes, and accessories that are new and used in good condition. 

They have expanded to sell home goods, electronics, bath and body, and toys. There are 7 pages of search results for Beanie Babies. Search by relevance, price high to low, price low to high, number of likes, recent shares, just in new listings, and items that have had recent price drops.  

6. Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is a unique buying and selling platform through Facebook. It does not charge sellers a listing fee for posting their items as Poshmark and Mercari do. Facebook Marketplace allows those with Facebook profiles to create listings for items other users can view to buy.

Facebook Marketplace allows for local pickup of items within a certain location radius as well as items that can be shipped for a fee. You can search for Shipping Only, Local Only, or Shipping & Local with a specified distance.

Facebook Marketplace can be a great place to find Beanie Babies that aren’t as readily available on other buying and selling platforms.

7. MyBeanieBabies.com

MyBeanieBabies.com is the best place to find and buy Beanie Babies online. We list our Beanie Babies in alphabetical order to make searching easier.

From Addison the Baseball Bear to Zoom the Sea Turtle, our Beanie Babies are authentic TY products ready to be shipped to you. Cuddly, huggable, and still oh so collectible, 

You can even buy Beanie Babies in bulk. They make great gifts for parents, teachers, and kids. But Beanie Babies are so cute and so much fun, you really don’t even need a reason to buy Beanie Babies.

The Best Place to Buy Beanie Babies

Now that you know the best place to buy Beanie Babies online, the hardest part will be choosing which ones you want to add to your collection or to give to someone else.

Each Beanie Baby has their own special personality and style. Browse our online stock of Beanie Babies at MyBeanieBabies.com

We have hundreds of Beanie Babies in stock. And we offer free shipping on orders over $50. 

Contact Us today to find the perfect Beanie Baby for you.